|Digital Edition — Year I, N°

Santa Jacinta News®

Fides • Traditio • Veritas

Chronicle of an Epistemological Fracture: The Abyss Between Faith and Modern Psychology (Part I) (Part 1)

Multidisciplinary academic research on the exhibition of Dr. Pablo Verdier Mazzara. Philological, theological and neuroclinical analysis of the rupture between the immanentist empirical clinic and pre-conciliar Christian anthropology, the encyclical Fides et Ratio and the crisis of the universities.

| By Editorial team |
Chronicle of an Epistemological Fracture: The Abyss Between Faith and Modern Psychology (Part I) (Part 1)

This essay constitutes the first installment of a monumental academic trilogy of journalistic, theological and neuroclinical research in which we propose to scrutinize with philological severity and Aristotelian-Thomistic rigor the masterful dissertation delivered by the eminent psychiatrist and Catholic thinker from the River Plate, Dr. Pablo Verdier Mazzara, around the burning and historical problem of the relationships between revealed faith and modern empirical psychology. Before descending into the epistemological dissection of the postulates presented in his conference, it is an imperative of intellectual honesty to place the figure of our interpellate in its correct academic dimension. Dr. Pablo Verdier Mazzara, a psychiatrist who graduated from the famous University of the Republic in the Banda Oriental of Uruguay and has lived in the Republic of Chile since 1996, has a career that admirably synthesizes hospital psychiatric clinical practice with solid philosophical speculation. With specialized postgraduate degrees in Philosophical Foundations from the Universidad de los Andes in Santiago de Chile and in Symbolic Psychotherapy from the Pontificia Universidad Católica Argentina, in addition to having a Master's degree in Integral Psychology of the Person and serving as president and founding member of the Association of Integral Psychology of the Person, Dr. Verdier has dedicated decades to teaching in the cloisters of the Finis Terrae University and the Pontifical University Catholic of Chile. However, the milestone that inscribes him with golden letters in the annals of Latin American Catholic thought is his titanic work as compiler and editor of the monumental work "Psychology and Psychiatry: Texts of the Pontifical Magisterium", published in Spain by the prestigious Library of Christian Authors after six arduous years of documentary archeology in the archives of L'Osservatore Romano. It is in the light of this formidable magisterial arsenal that, from my own investiture in this Santa Jacinta Publishing House as a multidisciplinary researcher - simultaneously trained in analytical chemistry, empirical neuroscience, philosophy of language and pre-conciliar metaphysics -, we undertake the present study.

For the contemporary secularized mentality, dulled by a mechanistic scientism that breathes the rarefied air of immanentist ideologies, even suggesting the existence of an intrinsic and substantial link between divine Revelation and empirical psychopathological clinic could resemble a rhetorical license devoid of any scientific value. However, critical examination stripped of positivist prejudices reveals that this question springs from the very core of common sense and the most basic phenomenal observation. Dr. Verdier Mazzara inaugurates his diagnosis not with abstract speculations or bell tower syllogisms, but by appealing to the irrefutable testimony of everyday phenomenology: the real case of a mother who seeks psychiatric assistance for her son in need of help. From my experience in the chemical analysis of neurodrugs and in the study of brain synapses, I witness daily how contemporary psychiatry has alarmingly degenerated into a mechanistic and reductionist materialism, where the patient is treated as a mere bag of neurotransmitters in imbalance and the medical practitioner is reduced to the status of a technical operator whose only competence lies in dispensing the correct molecular dose.

Back to news